A new Wilmington (N.C.) ballpark would create $172 million in direct spending and generate 3,952 new full- and part-time jobs, but opponents will find it to be less than persuasive when it comes to funding options.
The report from National Sports Services, released today in draft version, has been long awaited by proposed of a new ballpark for an Atlanta Braves farm team — the relocating Lynchburg Hillcats (High Class A; Carolina League), referred to in the report as the Wilmington Braves — to be managed by Mandalay Baseball Properties. And while the report, whose authors included 360 Architecture, CSL and BKP Consulting, may be a little rosy in term of impact — we really don’t believe a facility will have a $248-million impact in the city — we do agree with the central premise: that investing in a new ballpark will indeed lead to a financial payout for the city. But that probably won’t matter the low-tax advocates who dominate the public discussion.
Speaking of investment: NSS is recommending the city pay $26 million toward a new 6,000-seat ballpark costing between $36-42 million for construction, land and infrastructure. The sweet spot is 59 percent public funding; that’s been the national average for the last 20 or so years, says NSS. Mandalay’s rent of $400,000 a year — down significantly from earlier estimates, by the way — would generate $15.7 million, and a private developer would be asked to kick in $5.2 million.
The most fascinating part of the study: funding sources for a new ballpark. Wilmington is a very conservative city, so property taxes are among the lowest in the state. And while a survey indicated public support for a small property-tax hike to pay for a new ballpark, we’re not sure that would pass muster with voters. Instead, NSS laid out a few other sources of revenue that would have minimal impact on the locals, including a 3 percentage-point increase in hotel taxes, which would require state approval. This would generate $2.3 million annually, covering $31 million of debt service on a new ballpark.
In the end, we’re not thinking this report will end up swaying public opinion very much. The conservative foes of a new ballpark aren’t going to be persuaded by some fancy-talking out-of-town consultants telling them to raise property taxes to benefit rich out-of-town baseball-team owners. The tourism groups in Wilmington aren’t going to go down quietly while city officials mull raising tax rates to among the highest in the state. And you can bet The Big Talker is already talking up the part of the report showing that Mandalay Baseball Properties would be making an estimated 21 percent profit margin in the first year of ballpark operation. With opponents of public financing succeeding in putting the ballpark on a fall referendum, there’s already momentum on their side — and this report won’t counter it. It’s not quite dead on arrival, but the pulse is faint.
RELATED STORIES: Third time’s the charm: petition opposing Wilmington ballpark funding succeeds; More signatures tossed in Wilmington anti-ballpark petition drive;Opponents of Wilmington ballpark fail in petition drive; No ballpark money in upcoming Wilmington budget; “Free” land not so free in Wilmington; Referendum on horizon for new Wilmington ballpark; Wilmington ballpark sites down to three; poll indicates support; Mayor slams Wilmington ballpark financing proposal; Preferred site emerging for Wilmington ballpark?; Mandalay, Braves to update Wilmington on ballpark; Five potential ballpark sites under discussion in Wilmington; The race is on: NSS given marching orders in Wilmington; Wilmington bypasses Ripken Design as ballpark project manager; NSS is hired; Ripken Design chosen to oversee Wilmington ballpark planning; controversy ensues; Mandalay, Braves to pursue private financing for new Wilmington ballpark; Business leaders to push for new Wilmington ballpark; What should Wilmington expect for new-ballpark attendance?; Poll: Wilmington residents overwhelmingly oppose public financing of new ballpark; Proposed Wilmington lease: Mandalay would pay 12 percent of debt service; Atlanta Braves have tentative deal to buy Lynchburg Hillcats; New Wilmington ballpark would be part of hotel, marina complex; Wilmington to move forward with ballpark talks; Wilmington to discuss new Braves ballpark tomorrow night; Wilmington looks at development deal with Mandalay, Braves; Wilmington ballpark dead on arrival?; Another new effort for Wilmington minor-league baseball?
Share your news with the baseball community. Send it to us at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Are you a subscriber to the weekly Ballpark Digest newsletter? You can sign up for a free subscription at the Newsletter Signup Page.