By a narrow 4-3 margin, the El Paso City Council approved a proposed lease with MountainStar Sports for a new $50 million downtown ballpark for the relocating Tucson Padres (Class AAA; Pacific Coast League), but don’t assume the issue is settled — yet.
After hours and hours of public input on the new ballpark, the vote came along the exact lines everyone expected going in, with Rep. Emma Acosta switching her vote to no, as promised; the original ballpark proposal passed by a 6-2 margin, and with the absence of Rep. Steve Ortega (out on his honeymoon) and the switch of Acosta, the 4-3 vote was no surprise. Proposed amendments that would have put the ballpark to a public vote also failed by the same 4-3 margin.
So we have approval of a revised lease — for now. Mayor John Cook has 72 hours to either veto the lease or let it go, which would authorize the city manager to sign a lease with MountainStar for a new downtown ballpark opening in 2014. A 2 percentage point rise in the local hotel/motel tax would pay for most of the ballpark; the rest would come from rent and ticket surcharges. The rise in the hotel/motel tax would be subject to approval in the November elections, but as the lease is written now the city would need to find an alternative funding method should it be rejected.
Opposition to the ballpark came mainly from two groups: senior citizens against any large city expenditure and conservatives questioning whether the city should be in the ballpark business; support came from business leaders and younger citizens who see the ballpark as contributing to the city’s quality of life. Many also opposed tearing down City Hall to make room for the new ballpark, while others pointed out the city’s master plan calls for the demolition of City Hall in the next four years. We listened to most of the 140 citizens weighing in on the matter; there were thoughtful comments on both sides, as well as a few Abe Simpsons and a few starry-eyed optimists.
We expect Cook to receive lots of pressure from both sides. He tends to be on both sides of an issue; twice now he’s threatened a veto, only to come along the following day and walking back the threat, saying his concerns had been addressed. With only five votes supporting the ballpark (the four voting yes today plus Ortega), a veto would stand; it takes six to override. If Cook vetoes, then MountainStar and ballpark proponents will need to find a way to finance the ballpark — if the PCL doesn’t pull the permissions necessary to buy and move the team. So, basically, the future of PCL ball in El Paso relies on the decision of a single man, at this point.
RELATED STORIES: PCL approves move of T-Padres to El Paso — if lease approved; Rickey: El Paso could lose Triple-A team if ballpark not approved; MountainStar: Deal to bring Triple-A to El Paso could fall through if ballpark not approved; MountainStar, El Paso amend ballpark lease; El Paso mayor: I can still scuttle ballpark deal; Petition to halt El Paso ballpark submitted, but may be too late; El Paso moves forward with ballpark planning; El Paso group pledges profits to charity; Effort to thwart El Paso ballpark falls short; Protesters to “Occupy City Hall” over new El Paso ballpark; Hotel tax on El Paso ballot; no direct choice for voters; Will El Paso ballpark spur downtown development? Insiders of mixed mind; El Paso opponents: We want ballpark on fall ballot; PCL approves El Paso purchase of T-Padres; Foster: Opposition to new El Paso ballpark not a surprise; Opposition to El Paso ballpark emerges; Hoteliers: We don’t want to pay for new El Paso ballpark; El Paso group: we’re one step closer to buying PCL team; Pacific Coast League expected to decide El Paso bid for baseball this week; El Paso: Let’s sell Cohen Stadium to Tigua tribe; T-Padres back in Kino Stadium for 2013; One side effect of new El Paso ballpark: return of UTEP baseball; El Paso ownership group pitches PCL; El Paso approves ballpark for Triple-A team; First look: El Paso ballpark renderings; Diablos casualty of new El Paso ballpark; Downtown ballpark planning moving forward in El Paso; El Paso to debate ballpark bond issue; El Paso group seeking downtown ballpark, T-Pads; Moorad to Escondido: We need quick action on ballpark; Obstacles to new ballparks in California: not as bleak as expected; Escondido moving forward with business park on proposed ballpark property; City, not Moorad group, to acquire Escondido land; Escondido mayor: Time to scrap new-ballpark plan; Moorad: Leaving Padres in Tucson a possibility; Escondido ballpark vote put off indefinitely; Escondido ballpark vote delayed;State government could kill Escondido T-Pods ballpark; New for 2011: Tucson Padres; Escondido approves Triple-A ballpark — with reservations; Moorad group, Escondido sign MOU for new ballpark; Escondido council fills vacancy in advance of ballpark vote; Crunch time for new Escondido ballpark; Padres raise ante in Escondido ballpark negotiations; Escondido ballpark vote delayed again; new council will decide; Padres make it official: Beavers to Tucson in 2011; Election shows mixed support for new Escondido ballpark; Tuesday elections could determine fate of Bevos; Bevos to Tucson for 2011; Escondido ballpark vote delayed after pollution found at site; Fate of Bevos in the air until November, maybe December; Padres pitch one-sided lease to Escondido; Escondido: Show us some money, Padres; Escondido in, San Marcos out of Bevos ballpark mix
Share your news with the baseball community. Send it to us at email@example.com.
Are you a subscriber to the weekly Ballpark Digest newsletter? You can sign up for a free subscription at the Newsletter Signup Page.